Unsuccessful Advertising

August 19, 2009 – 8:47 AM

Two jewels in the Russell Library’s collection of campaign ads come from the Carl Sanders collection. In 1970 Sanders ran a losing race against Jimmy Carter, whose populist message effectively countered the image Sanders cultivated: the cool competence of a former governor and skilled attorney. The Sanders 1970 campaign, unsuccessful as it may have been, yielded some of the more interesting political ads ever televised.

In 1969 Sanders hired the Burton Campbell Advertising Agency to develop his public image. One of Burton Campbell’s chief creative writers was Hugh Wilson (who would later find great success as writer and producer of WKRP in Cincinnati). Wilson was enamored with the work of the Maysles brothers, creators of “direct cinema” documentaries whose art was elevating the ordinary or, conversely, bringing the extraordinary back down to earth (check out the Gimme Shelter or Grey Gardens, two of their masterpieces). Wilson hired Albert Maysles to shoot the ads, and in the summer of 1969 Maysles followed Sanders for four days, shooting five hours of film. Two longer commercials were edited from this footage, with, as Sanders’s confidante Judge Norman Underwood put it, “impressive but not persuasive” results. Hugh Wilson put it this way: “I’m the man who got Jimmy Carter elected governor of Georgia.” Enjoy!


“Running Again”

Craig Breaden’s article on the Sanders/Maysles campaign ads, “Carl Sanders and Albert Maysles: Direct Cinema meets Georgia Politics, 1969” appears this fall in the Journal The Moving Image.


  1. 5 Responses to “Unsuccessful Advertising”

  2. nice article, I didn’t know Huge Wilson was involved with Jimmy Carter. He must be a great writer.Bet he made a lot of money on the WKRP…I loved that show.

    By Jefferson Money on Sep 14, 2009

  3. Really, this article is providing very good information about Sanders and putting a light on his life.

    By Jennifer Stevenson on Dec 7, 2009

  4. It really should be noted that there are several possible reasons why advertising doesn’t work all the time. One really overlooked reason is that the product or the message (all by itself) does not resonate with the target audience. If the goods are faulty or you’re trying to sell it to the wrong person, success is always out of reach.

    By Steve Marsel on Jan 3, 2010

  5. Great read, I love seeing older articles about how the advertising agencies have great effect on politics. Doesn’t happen often.

    By PAPA on Jul 29, 2010

  6. “impressive but not persuasive” was the right words!

    By B. Terente on Jun 24, 2011

Post a Comment